Latest Update:  May 12, 1991

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 2

   I have another cavil with the Schmidt-Cassegrain telescopes, in
addition to what I say in MFT2. We were discussing the flexure put on
the thin correcting plate by the weight of the secondary mirror and its
mounting. I said there, that the larger the diameter of the telescope
and its correcting plate, the more the strain on that plate. Let's add
that the shorter the focal length of the system, the larger the secondary
mirror and its mounting, and thus the greater the strain on the correct-
ing plate and the more the light from the heavens is blocked by that
secondary.

   So those f6.3 Schmidt-Cassegrains will have larger secondaries than
are necessary for an f10, for example, and thus more flexure, less
brightness, and less contrast for a given object. Their only saving
graces are that they have wider fields of view with a given eyepiece in
comparison with the f10 models and they can achieve the combination of
that wider field of view and lower power with a shorter focal length
eyepiece than an f10 requires for that magnification.

   "You aren't going out to left field again, are you, Rosenfield? What
is the advantage of a shorter focal length eyepiece?"

   Audrey, I guess you haven't bought any eyepieces lately. For someone
using an f10 to get to a desired low powered magnification--and thus the
wider field, that person has to buy a long focus eyepiece. They are
EXPENSIVE. Another problem with the long focus oculars is they certainly
absorb more light than a simpler ocular with fewer lens elements. To
partly overcome that light absorption, their makers apply multi-coatings
to improve light transmission. But you can get the shorter focal length
oculars with those coatings too.

   "That's not too clear either, Don. Why would anyone WANT a lower
power? Don't telescope users want as much power as possible?"

   Wow! What a question! Aside from the problems inherent in the
discussion we had in MFT2, about the differences between surface
accuracy, wave front accuracy, and system accuracy, there is the
problem of SEEING. On almost every clear night (or day if what you are
observing is our sun, a bright comet, or the brighter planets), the
images you see in the various telescopes available at star parties,
back yard groups, family outings, or whatever, will always be a
steadier view of the celestial wonders with a smaller diameter
telescope, given the same quality of clock-driven heavy duty mountings
well-aligned on the invisible pole.

   The reason for that is the fractal turbulence of our atmosphere (which
is not possible to predict). Due to that, and the kind of observing I
started doing in 1953, variable star observing:  98% of the time, I
magnified 32X. In over thirty years of observing with that and other
instruments (the 20"f4 at CMU and the 8" Clark at USP, on both of which I
used my own oculars) I went to a higher power eyepiece less than a dozen
times. One important point is that the lower power will give a wider
field of view.

   Another is that the lower the power, the steadier the image. On many
nights you can use 3 to 4X per inch of mirror diameter, before the image
starts breaking up. On a few better nights you can move up to 6X to
7X/inch of diameter before the image starts breaking up and you have to
go to a lower power. On yet better nights--or better times in the same
night as conditions can be stable or changing--you can go to 25X to
30X/inch. You can use 50X/inch but two or three times a year. Once every
year and a half to two years, the atmosphere is steady enough to let you
use the highest power eyepieces you have, up to 100X/inch of diameter; if
you try to use more power, the image is impaired and useless.

   "I feel another question coming on here, Don. Assuming what you say
is correct--and how could I doubt someone awarded a whole file folder
just for his essays (Jeff Alu has his own file folder but that's for
announcement telegrams and space news transmitted to him)--how does that
discussion affect the differences, say between an f4 and an f10 of the
same diameter objective?"

   You need to watch that sarcasm, Audrey. It started to creep in there
a bit, again. Sure! You are right! It critically affects the decision
on whether to design and build, to design and have someone else build for
you, or to purchase a ready-made telescope. I think that a lot of people
who buy Schmidt-Cassegrains don't really know what they bought. They
think of the telescope as a Schmidt-Cassegrain without knowing what
either a Schmidt Camera is or what a Cassegrain is.

   A Schmidt-Cassegrain is a hybrid design. It developed from the
Cassegrain, which has been around for hundreds of years, and the Schmidt
Camera that was developed in Germany in 1930. The Schmidt is a wide-
field photographic (or CCD) telescope without an eyepiece. The reason
there isn't an eyepiece is that the focal plane of the Schmidt is curved.
The way you access the image (Boy! I love to write astronomical jargon.)
is to bend a thin glass photographic plate to fit that focal plane. I'm
not sure how you would use a CCD at that focus.

   "What? YOU admit there's something in the field of telescopes you
don't know?"

   Grrr. The Cassegrain is a two mirror system. The primary mirror....
Here, let's use my 10"f4 as an example, especially as I started out to
make a Cassegrain. Okay. The focal length is 40 inches. The field of
view with a 32mm eyepiece is 2. When I found that I had to figure the
secondary, which is a hyperbolic convex surface, used inside the
primary's focus, I said, "No problem."  If I can figure a 1/38 wave
surface accuracy primary, I'll just do the opposite for the convex
hyperbola.

   But it isn't quite that simple. When you make a concave parabola, for
any given diameter and focal length of mirror, there is one sphere, an
infinite number of ellipses, one parabola, and an infinite number of
hyperbolas. You have to hit that one parabola. Don't be scared by that.
If I can do it, you can do it. When I was your age, I could take a pair
of 6 inch diameter Pyrex discs, examine them for bubbles near the surface
turning the one with the most bubbles there into a tool and the other
into an 1/8 wave parabola in 10 hours of working time. [Not including
pressing time or testing time. (After breaking my spine in two auto
accidents, don't ask me to make any more mirrors! I'm just grateful to
be alive.)]

   Getting back to the Cassegrain secondary, in order to figure it, your
test setup needs a flat mirror the same size as your primary mirror.
That flat has to be figured to a greater level of accuracy than the
system you are testing. The amount of work involved in making a 10"
flat with surface accuracy of 1/100 wave (and thus a wave front of 1/50
wave) is daunting. But that is what standard manufacturers of Casse-
grains do. It isn't worth it for just one telescope. It is certainly
worth it if you are in production.

   So what I did was decide to make a Dall-Kirkham which has an
elliptical primary (easier to make than a parabola) and a spherical
convex secondary. The sphere is the easiest surface to make. I went as
far as cutting the hole nearly through the center of my 10" mirror in the
fine grinding stage and cutting it through near the end of the polishing
stage. It was no loss, as where the hole is, is covered by the shadow of
the elliptical diagonal. (Elliptical diagonals cause much less diffrac-
tion effects than other diagonal shapes.)

   But then, after taking my f4 down past the sphere (it was spherical to
1/20 wave) I couldn't bear not having the Newtonian focus. So I never
made a convex secondary. If I needed more power I just placed the Goodwin
Barlow (I bought it from Frank Goodwin, a fellow Chicago Astronomical
Society member.) in the eyepiece holder and the eyepiece into the Barlow.
The Barlow gives you from 2X to 3X the power of the eyepiece you use.
However, it should be kept in mind that the Barlow acts like the lens on
an enlarger. It can't add information to the light bundle aimed at your
pupil. All it can do is read the information supplied by the objective.

   Remember though that astronomers, both amateur and professional, use
the least power consistent with their goals. The lowest usable power
gives, as above, the widest and steadiest field of view. It also gives
the greatest eye relief, the distance from your pupil to the ocular's
focus. Eye relief is more important to those who wear glasses as a short
eye relief ocular doesn't leave room for your glasses. That is more
important to those observers who have astigmatism. Those who wear
glasses just for far or near sightedness, but without astigmatism don't
need their glasses while using a telescope. The only difference is that
the ocular will focus in a different place. An ocular I got as a present
is an achromatic zoom. While the view at any given magnification isn't
quite as good as the higher quality individual oculars, it is useful when
you are trying to find an individual star or other object that just isn't
visible at the lower powers.

   Zoom lenses are available for cameras; the same circumstances apply-
ing. Any given effective focal length of lens using the zoom lens is not
(nor can be) as sharp as that focal length of a single focal length lens,
given equal quality of manufacture.

   Audrey, I guess you've been waiting on two of those bent nails used
for holding cloth on a framework, that is, on tenterhooks, for me to
answer your question. But as I'm just dreaming you up (There surely
can't be a Audrey Wright, can there?) I get to go off on tangents.

   Ok, on any given night, with its degree of fractal turbulence, you
want to use the least amount of power consistent with optical design
parameters.

   "Jargon, Rosenfield, watch it. Gee, I like to give subjunctive
commands. I don't know what you mean by `optical design parameters.'"

   Well, for one thing, if you exceed a 7mm diameter exit pupil with your
combination of telescope and ocular, you vignette (that is, cut down) the
effective diameter of your telescope. An easy example is that of prism
binoculars. A 7X50 has a 50mm objective and magnifies 7 times. The exit
pupil can be measured by holding the binocular away from your face and
pointed at a bright wall (Please don't point it at our sun.). In your
other hand you hold a ruler divided into millimeters. Measure the image
seen through the ocular.

   You will see, that, every time, the measurement comes out 7.1mm. You
can get that figure another way. Divide the diameter in millimeters by
the magnification:  50 / 7 = 7.1  The expanded diameter of the human
pupil, in darkness, is closer to 8mm when you are about 12 years old
(Parents of young children should pay attention to this section.)  When
you reach 12 years you have the highest visual acuity (sharpness) of your
life; it's all downhill from there. The 80 year old person can't expand
their pupil more than about 2mm. So when you are young, a 7X50
binocular, with it's 7.1mm exit pupil makes sense. When you are 70 years
old you can use the same 7X50 you used when you were young, but the same
brightness won't be there. If your pupil can't expand more than 4mm,
say, any glass outside of 28mm of your binocular's objectives are
vignetted. As you age you probably want a binocular that weighs less,
also. There are other examples among binoculars. An 8X40 has an exit
pupil of 5mm. So does a 7X35.

   Okay, let's go back to telescopes. My 3"f5 RRFT (described in MFT2)
working at 10X, gives a 7.62mm exit pupil. (Divide the 76.2mm diameter
by the 10X.)  My 10"f4, working at 32X (actually 31.75X) has a diameter
of 254mm and an exit pupil of 8mm. With a one inch (25.4mm) ocular, the
resultant exit pupil is 6.35mm.

   The following discussion picks up where we left off, before the above
divertissement on optical parameters.

   So, taking a 10" mirror as an example, and using it at f4, let's say
the night is a bit better than standard, just good enough for 8X per inch
of diameter. 8 X 10 = 80X. If your telescope is a Newtonian or has a
Newtonian focus, you put in an ocular that gives that 80 power, that is,
a half inch focus lens.

   Now, how do you get to that 80 power upper limit with a Cassegrain?
The Cassegrain gives an effective focal length (e.f.l.) four times the
focal length of the Newtonian. (Another design, the Gregorian, which uses
a concave secondary past the focal point of the primary, gives an e.f.l.
six times that focal length.)  So a 10"f4 with a Cassegrain secondary has
a focal length of 160 inches. (A Gregorian would have a focal length of
240 inches on the same telescope.)  Thus for the eyepiece needed to get
to 80X, you need a two inch focal length lens. To get to the 40X, where
the f4 shines, on the Cassegrain you would need a four inch focal length
lens. I don't see such a long focus eyepiece listed for sale.

   The Schmidt-Cassegrain, usually made in f10, has a thin, complex
correcting plate holding a secondary, the starlight going through the
corrector to the primary, back to the secondary, and then through a hole
in the primary to a camera or to a right angle focuser. If most nights
are going to allow the finest observing or photographing with but 4X per
inch of primary, you don't want the Schmidt-Cassegrain or any Cassegrain.

   You don't even want a long focus Newtonian. Planetary observers might
have a second telescope for planetary use. But they have the same
problems of seeing that wide-field observers have.

   What you want for a first telescope is a wide-field, short focus
Newtonian. In MFT2 I suggested that Tim Pyle, with his limited time, get
a Questar. If he indicated--which he didn't--a burgeoning interest in
our hobby--citing time constraints--I would have recommended for him what
I do for others. In my astronomy classes I advised my students
interested in making their own mirrors to make an 8"f5 for a first
mirror. In my astronomy book (still in manuscript form) I advise the
reader to make an 8"f6--though I give instructions on how to make an
f5--just because it is easier and in the small towns where many of my
readers live, there might not be anyone to help them. My wife made
Elizabeth, the 6"f8 she made for a high school science fair (Yes, it won
the top prize.) with nobody in Lansing, Michigan to help her. As far as
the officers of the Lansing Astronomical Society could determine, nobody
in Lansing had ever made a telescope. When she was 18, Chris was
president of the LAS and their delegate to the Astronomical League
Convention, which, as I noted elsewhere, is where I met her.

   If the night improves or you have a better night to start with, you
can put in a 2X Barlow, (Make sure you use an achromatic Barlow in place
of the simple lens Barlows on the market.)  giving in the case of a 10"f4
an effective focal ratio of f8. With a 3X Barlow you have an effective
focal ratio of f12, which not only is longer than the f10 Schmidt-
Cassegrains, but doesn't have the several lens or mirror surfaces which
degrade quality (as discussed in MFT2). The effect of that combination
is that a one-inch focal length eyepiece used in a 10"f4 gives 40X; with
the 2X Barlow the magnification is 80X; and with the 3X Barlow the
magnification is 120X. You can see then that a " eyepiece in those
cases, will give: 80X, 160X, and 240X. A " gives 160X, 320X, and 480X.
How often can you use those higher powers? Not often, friend, not often.
In laboratory conditions, though, it's possible to go to higher powers,
assuming your optics are good enough for such service. The Questar is
routinely used for such work. The highest power I ever tried with my
3.5" Questar was 600X. I got that high using extension tubes.

 
                --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist
                                         (All Rights Reserved)
