Latest Update:  May 14, 1991

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 3

   "I just had a thought about the Schmidt-Cassegrains (SC). Why are
they made in f10 . . . and just what is a SC?"

   Lemme answer your second question first. The Schmidt-Cassegrain has
a short focus mirror that can't bring light to a focus due to its
severe spherical aberration. It's been a while since I looked at the
figures, but as I remember them, the primary mirror is either an f1 or
f2, though probably you could use either one, with the proper change
in the rest of the system. Figured to a spherical surface, the primary
needs some system to correct that sphere. The thin secondary corrector
plate has a descendant's relationship, I believe, with the Ross
correcting plate used on the five meter Hale to widen the field of
view, at the cost of the superb definition at the center of that field
without the corrector.

   The SC's correcting plate refracts (bends) the light rays coming in
near the edge (and tapering down to near the center) of that plate.
The refracted light rays bend outwards from the plate on their way to
the primary mirror.

   "But Uncle Don, if the plate's rays are bent outward, does that
mean the correcting plate is smaller than the primary?"

   Good for you, Audrey. Yes, when you buy a SC or a Maksutov Casse-
grain (MC), the 3.5", 7", 8", 10", 11", 14" or whatever is the
diameter of the primary, not of the correcting plate. Okay, we have a
short focus primary mirror and a correcting plate with a peculiar
curvature on its front surface. Now, for the SC we need a convex
secondary mirror in-between the primary and the corrector. (The MC
uses a slightly different system.)  The light travels from the
secondary, through a hole in the primary and is processed from that
location with your choice of diagonal mirror, right angle or Amici
prism, camera or CCD.

   For your first question, let's compare the difference between a f10
and a say, f16 SC. The f10 has a larger secondary mounting than the
f16. We already know, from our previous discussion in Rambling
Thoughts 2, that the weight and size of the larger secondary causes
more flexure, gives less contrast, and less brightness than a f16.
Remember that the SC is a hybrid design as noted in RT2. The normal
Cassegrain telescope is a f16. Admittedly, a f16 would make the tube
longer and the mounting a bit more bulky. But we're talking use in the
field, not in the closet of unused instrumentation, here folks.

   "But we have to consider which eyepieces to use in balance with the
seeing conditions of any given night, don't we, Don? And another
thing. With a combination Newtonian-Cassegrain, we can switch
secondaries, especially if the telescope is designed for easy
switching. There is no Newtonian focus on the SC. Other than going to
longer focus oculars, about the only thing you can do is to use
four-element Celestron's f6.3 converter (when used on an f10). That
converter also fits Meade telescopes."

   Right, Audrey. Though with a four-element corrector added to the
3-element SC system plus whatever kind of star diagonal plus whatever
kind of ocular--and there are some wild ones out there--getting used
... At the last OCA Anza party I went to, I brought along my WWII war
surplus 32mm 6-element Erfle. Several members were fascinated by the
sharp field of view with that ocular, as used with their telescopes. I
use it as the main ocular for my 10"f4, giving the 2 field mentioned
elsewhere. When I need a bit more light, say when needing faint
comparisons for a variable star, I go to my Brandon 32mm orthoscopic
eyepiece, which, gives the same magnification, a smaller field of
view, and incomparable definition.  I don't think I paid more than
about $25 for it; of course that was before 1960.

   Let's look at the f10-f16 comparison. Again, just for ease, let's
use a 10" diameter. And, for that matter, we are using the f10
specification, even knowing it is actually f10.25. A one inch f.l.
ocular used at f10 gives 100X, a 1/2 gives 200X, and a 1/4 gives 400X.
Used at f16, those same oculars give 160X, 320X, and 640X. Obviously,
the longer focal length f16 is not going to be usable most nights of
the year. If we go to a two inch ocular, using it at f10 gives 50X and
at f16 gives 80X. That widens the number of nights to those when
5X/inch or 8X/inch are usable.

   "I think we have covered the field of SC design, except for one
subject that's been tantalizing the right side of the spot between my
ears. What is the figure of the back side of the SC correcting plate.
I know you said that the MCs corrector, the meniscus lens, has two
spherical surfaces corrected to 1/64 wave surface accuracy. But I'm a
little nervous about the SC's plate."

   So am I. That might be something a prospective purchaser (who has
read these musings) might ask the manufacturer. In MFT2 I assumed that
the Meade and Celestron plates were figured, front and back to the
1/10 wave surface accuracy they advertise. But is that backside
figured at all? In one of the reviews, noted above, speaking of
Celestron's procedures, the author said that a thin sheet of glass was
subjected to the vacuum process to figure the front side. Nothing,
however, was said about the backside. If it isn't figured; if it is
put into operation with the figure it had when it arrived at the
plant, we are going to have to say that the system accuracy of the SC
(with 1/10 wave surface accuracy and no figuring on the back of the
corrector), using a prism star diagonal, is a minimum of 1 wave and a
maximum of down the street and around the corner. Remember Minor
White's comparison between my 10" Newtonian and his 10" SC in MFT2?
Minor couldn't get over the crispness of my images compared with his.
What does that say about the system accuracy of his telescope?

   Are any of you stamp collectors? I'm using one of the appendices in
my astronomy book to list and illustrate some of the astronomical sub-
jects on stamps. That's going to require time spent going through the
stamp catalogs to find them. I know that they were issued by the U.S,
the Soviet Union, Great Britain, Poland, Hungary, Japan, Korea, etc. I
do have the American Topical Society's booklet on the subject, but
suggestions are welcome.

   Won't it be nice, folks? No more getting cut off in mid-sen

   Sorry about that. I think I got hit by a cosmic ray. Speaking of
which, we should--if we haven't done it before--take a close look at
our credit and bank statements for 1989. The problem with committing
our finances to computers is that they are vulnerable to cosmic rays,
which can turn a 1 into a 0 (or a 0 into a 1). Another place where
computers are antsy--or maybe I'm just antsy on this subject--is
people who work with floppy disks, or when needed with their mother's
case open, and simultaneously smoke. Good Grief! Smoke particles are
TINY. They can get onto the media's surface and change a 1 into a 0.

   When my wife was a research chemist at Dow Chemical in Midland,
Michigan (she was employed as a synthesist rather than as a
specialist), one day some Dow VIPs came into her lab. My 26 year old
wife walked up to the Vice-President of Dow Chemical, took the
cigarette out of his mouth and put it out. She was complimented by
those folks who hadn't quite realized what they were doing, walking
into Christine Rosenfield's lab with a lighted cigarette. She was
working with a Coulter counter, measuring particles.

   The smoke could have ruined many hours of work. It can ruin a
floppy disk or a hard disks' storage of a program or any of many of
the things we do. (An example is you don't want to smoke while working
on a stamp collection. The smoke is deposited on the stamps--and
everything else in your house. Stamps so treated will not last as
those which don't have those complex molecules deposited on them.)
That's without consideration of the primary or secondary damage
cigarette smoke causes in our bodies and in the bodies of our loved
ones.

   Most literate people who smoke know of the damage they are causing
themselves and the people around them. My wife says that one thing
they don't take into consideration is the fact that if they are fated
to die due to their smoking habit, that death will come after almost
unbearable agony. That is something she deals with every day, working
as she does in a senior health center. One thing about sitting in
front of a computer and doing your own thing in your house is that if
you are a smoker, you get to ruin your own lungs, those of your
family, and your own floppy and hard disks; the nonsmoker gets to
breathe the air untroubled by smoke.

   Chris and the Coulter counter. Gee, that brings back memories. When
Chris got her Ph.D. (18 years before she got her M.D.) she had many
offers of where to go to work. The most money was offered by Texaco in
Houston who had some 15,000 foot deep wells in California. One percent
of the oil at the bottom of the wells was coming out the top. That
deep a well is too deep to allow well casings, so 99 percent of the
oil was leaking away to the sides. Texaco wanted her to make 100
percent more come out, that is two percent. They needed and she was, a
surfactant chemist. But we didn't want to live in Houston. Chris was
primarily a physical chemist, but also an inorganic chemist, a
formulation chemist, a surfactant chemist and a lover of cats.

   We had black cats, mostly, though our 17lb Vigoro was a long-haired
black and white. While we lived in Canada we ate a fair amount of elk
venison, ducks, great northern pike, ling cod, and rabbits. One day I
came home with several jack rabbits. Chris and I have an agreement. If
I bring home fish or fowl or anything else that is legal, I catch
them, I clean them, she cooks them, and we eat them. Once I brought
home a large black bird. While not legal anymore, they were then. She
cooked and we ate it. But . . . I thought she was going to use the
recipe for crow, which is to put the crow and a stone in a pot. You
boil salty water in that pot for seven hours. Your dinner is ready so
you take out the crow and toss it out and serve the now-tender stone.

   Well I gave Vigoro one of those jack rabbits, as he was watching me
clean them and said in a mixture of meows, purrs, and growls, that as
the man of the house (mouse catching variety) he should get some of
the booty. I didn't skin or otherwise clean Vigoro's share. He thanked
me, picked up the jack rabbit, and disappeared into the basement. In
one night that cat ate that whole nine pound rabbit, skin, hair,
bones, and all. The next evening he was announcing that he was ready
for his regular dinner.

   We tossed Vigoro out every night. He would be found sitting on our
front step. His major ambition in life was to come in the house.
Instead of the normal 5 toes on each paw, he had 7 toes. If a dog
challenged Vigoro's territorial rights on that front step, Vigoro
would lift one of those tremendous paws, spread out his 7 claws, and
say, "Peace."  Once a neighbor said she saw two streaks go past her
house. The front streak was a white dog. The rear streak was our
normally ponderously moving black and white Vigoro. Ponderous or not,
his favorite spot was lying down--and purring loudly--on my chest
while I was lying on a couch and reading.

   Chris has even offered my duck cleaning services to neighbors.
Whilst going to school, I worked afternoons and Saturdays in my dad's
meat market/grocery store. Speaking of my dad, he started driving in
1916, finally stopping last year. How many people can beat that
record?

   "I guess it's a waste of time asking you what all this has to do
with cosmogony. Gee. I like that word. It has a smoother sound and
feel than the rougher word, cosmology."

   Right. The cosmogony, which deals with everything, comes and goes
in its intensity. Just think how Earth's population would be entranced
by these essays . . . if we were inhabitants of a different solar
system. Every word would be hung on. I have readers (of my No News
letters and of my book manuscripts) that hang on every word I write.

   If you could visit Shirley Schwartz' house in Warren, Michigan,
you'd see a file of everything I've ever written to her. Shirley gets
mentioned in Chapter 15 of my astronomy ms. She and I brainstormed the
evolution of our Universe theory one night; her engineer husband gave
up, he couldn't follow us. Of course I couldn't leave the prose in
that state. I had to--while keeping the theory functional--make it
understandable to my intended audience, which is middle school honors
science students and up. While my prime audience is the world of
amateur and armchair astronomers, probably the largest number of
readers will be among the 26 million Americans who subscribe to
science magazines.

   "Shirley sounds interesting, Don. What does she do for a living?"

   Shirley was one of my wife's roommates when both were studying
chemistry at the U. of M. Shirley got her Ph.D. in biochemistry and
taught for a number of years. During the years starting in 1971 after
we returned from Brazil, each semester while Shirley was teaching
Natural Science at Oakland Community College, she had me come in and
team teach astronomy and mineralogy. After Shirley transferred to
Detroit Institute of Technology to teach biochemistry, my wife
inherited Shirley's course work at OCC. As Chris knew a great deal
about astronomy, I team taught mineralogy in her classes. When Chris
started teaching at U. of M. and entered medical school, I inherited
the OCC course. All three of us acquired the title of Assistant
Professor of Natural Science.

  Shirley worked at BASF for several years and for the last 10 years
at GM's Tech Center in Warren. GM doesn't use Shirley's system in
their cars, but all GM's plant operations use her hydraulic system. I
don't know exactly what she did to the water molecule, but GM uses
water in those hydraulics rather than the oil everyone else uses.
Shirley is active in the fraternity of Lubrication Engineers, speaking
on that subject in French while in France, and in German while in
Germany.

As you can see, I think I'm rambling. If Walter gets enough nay votes
he'll tell me to stop. I might stop anyway, as I'm sure to run out of
things to say.

   "Yeah, in thirty-five or forty-five years, Don."

   Maybe. I think a generation of people who live in Michigan's Tri-
County area (Midland, Bay, and Saginaw counties) are spoiled. Whenever
they see the Little Dipper they automatically think, "Yeah, what was
it Rosenfield said in the Planetarium over at Delta College? I
remember! He said the Little Dipper is used to scoop ice cream out of
the Big Dipper."

   Where am I in this essay. How did I get off the subject of Chris'
job hunting? Was it something to do with a cat? Oh yeah. It was that,
" . . . lover of cats."

   Dow offered two things that nobody else in the industry offered.
The first was, after you have retired, and if you are good enough, you
can come back at 3/4 salary and work on anything you wanted. (Chris
thought she was good enough.)  The second thing was that, if you are
good enough--and few chemists are this good--after 20 years on the job
you can pick all your own projects rather than have someone else tell
you what to do. Both of those perks are offered only to Ph.D.
chemists.

   Chris, fresh out of grad school, (She had taken a 5 year program in
chemistry at the U. of Michigan in 3 years, skipped the master's and
took her Ph.D. in 3 years) reported to Dow's formulation lab, which
she would work out of for the next 7-1/2 years, six weeks early. They
hadn't expected to see her that quickly. The new building they were in
was still under construction; there wasn't even a women's john yet.

   Shades of medical school. Chris was a member of Phi Rho Sigma, a
medical fraternity. On her floor of the frat house there were 17 men,
2 women (incl. her) and two bathrooms. So many women have joined PRS
since then that they changed their status of being a frat to that of
being a society. I don't know how they managed it, but members and
significant others of that frat always had reserved seats at the 50
yard line for the home U. of Michigan football games. I took advantage
of that several times. The roar of the crowd with over 100,000
people--for every game--was matched only by the radiation you pick up
from all those bodies so close to you.

   As I said, she reported and they gave her the assignment of setting
up the Coulter counter. A complex machine, it takes someone with a
Ph.D. six weeks to set it up so someone with just a masters' degree in
chemistry can operate it. They figured she'd be out of their hair for
some time. They next saw her about 4 hours later. She had finished the
assignment and asked for something else to do.

   Oh, yeah, that "second thing" I noted, above? Chris got to that
point in six weeks flat. After working there six weeks, for the
balance of her time at Dow she picked her own projects. One example
should suffice. I don't even know if anyone reads these . . . naaah,
maybe two examples.

   In 1963, Chris became aware that Dow physics had a rather messy
problem. The Corvette car bodies--ever since the first of them--were
splitting longitudinally. They were made of a layer of fiberglass, a
layer of cement, a layer of fiberglass, etc. That calls for a
surfactant chemist, one who works at the joint edges of any two solids
or fluids. (A fluid can be a gas or a liquid. So our sun and the other
stars, without any solids, are all fluids.)  All Chris had to do was
to get the molecules of cement to bond in a locking arrangement with
the molecules of fiberglass. She solved the problem in one month and
went back to her formulation lab. Chevrolet and Dow never had that
problem recur.

   We don't know how this next experience worked out. But it sure was
interesting as far as we know. As a synthesist, Chris attended an ACS
National Society meeting in New York, probably in 1967. She moved
around, looking at displays, attended seminars, and kept her mouth
shut! On her return to Midland, she applied what she had learned in
New York--the chemists there would never have gone in the direction
she did--to the work one of her colleagues, Ted Holmson, was doing.
He, also, would never have gotten where she took him. She had come up
with a chemical. Boy, what a chemical.

   "I don't understand, Uncle Don. Isn't a Dow chemist supposed to
come up with chemicals? That's what she's paid for, isn't it?"

   Okay, let's verve over from chemistry to biology. If you take a
plant, that for example, has a leaf that has three lobes and cut off
one of the lobes, that leaf now has two lobes, right?

   "Of course. I don't see where you are leading me. By the way, Uncle
Don, I like your use of Socratic writing. It let's me stick my two
cents in, every once in a while."

   You're welcome, Audrey. I enjoy our conversations. What if you took
that leaf with now but two lobes and--probably by grafting--caused it
to grow and have progeny, that is, other leaves. How many lobes will
those daughter leaves have?

   "What's this? A trick question? Are you testing me? It will have
three leaves, of course."

   Sure, YOU see that right away. When I tell this to a class of teen-
agers, they waffle and come up with strange answers. Anyone, however,
who can run a computer and a modem will know the right answer, and in
many cases look askance at me for asking it.

   But what if you treated that two-lobed leaf with the chemical
substance my wife came up with? The progeny of that leaf had TWO
lobes. I'm not kidding. Dow thought so much of what she and Ted had,
that they sent Ted, on full Dow salary for a year to work with the
Nobel prize winner, Dr. Melvin Calvin at Caltech. The last we heard,
just before we left for our three years in Brazil, was that Holmson
and Calvin had successfully applied Chris' formula to animals. They
were looking for a cancer cure or whatever else might turn up. When we
got back from Brazil, the formulation lab was gone, Ted wasn't there,
and Chris started taking the biology classes preparatory to her going
to medical school. As I said when I started this, we never did find
out what happened, but it was sure interesting.


           --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/ice cream scooper
                                (All Rights Reserved)

Again I want to note these reserved rights. Much of what I'm feeding
you comes out of my (not quite ready for publication) "Zen and the Art
of Marriage."
