Latest Update:  March 7, 1992

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 32

Happy Michelangelo's Birthday!

The theme for this essay derives from Message 3343, written by Eric
 Newman. He asks for my comments on the _Sky & Telescope_ article,
 "Optical Quality in Telescopes" by Peter Ceravolo, Terence Dickinson,
 and Douglas George of Ontario, Canada in the March 1992 issue.

Eric has some other questions, including my opinion of Coulter
 telescopes. First the mirror and then the mounting. Coulter sells
 1/8 wave surface accuracy mirrors for use in Dobsonian mountings. I
 still find it strange that a telescope builder can build a mounting
 that he sees in a book, in this case the modified _Couder_ altazimuth
 in Texereau's book *and then have the mounting named after him*!!!
 That is the derivation of the name Dobsonian. Dobson built a
 modified Couder and calls it a Dobsonian. Great. I can build a
 Dobsonian and call it a Rosenfieldian. [And, I suppose, Couder can
 build a Rosenfieldian and call it a Couder, so we've come full
 circle!]

Right, Eric. The Coulter 1/8 wave surface accuracy mirrors in a
 Newtonian design, gives a derived system accuracy (S.A.) of 1/2 wave,
 assuming certain givens. Those are:

 1) If they are testing with a  Foucault test device, is the knife
 edge fixed or movable. All other options aside, if the knife edge is
 movable then the S.A. is 1/2 wave. If the knife edge is fixed then
 the system accuracy is 1 wave.

 2) Is the advertised 1/8 wave surface accuracy actually 1/8 wave or
 is it plus or minus 1/8 wave . . . which is 1/4 wave. That combined
 with a fixed knife edge gives a 2 wave S.A.. Now, I don't know that
 the Coulter mirrors are that bad; I'm just showing you that you must
 query the manufacturer as to which system they are using.

 Though I note that in the _S & T_ article George comments about,
 " . . . there simply is an abundance of 1-wave light buckets out
 there."  He is talking about a 1 wave wave front (W.F.), not system
 accuracy. That would be up to 2 waves, depending on the quality of
 the diagonal. And . . . surely them what manufacture 1 W.F. primaries
 don't supply well-made diagonals to go with them. (Sorry, _Pogo_
 syntax keeps creeping in.)

 Anyone who had read my MFTs and my RTs would have already known the
 results printed in that article. They'd be on familiar ground.
 There's nothing in the article that differs from the results I've
 been writing--and teaching--for forty years.

 The authors comment that for most observers and for most seeing
 conditions, a lesser quality mirror is adequate. Adequate? For OCA
 members? Sure, you can use a 1/2 wave S.A. telescope (implying 1/8
 wave surface accuracy as is advertised) most nights and not notice
 improvement when comparing with a better instrument. But what do you
 do when the seeing is better than normal. Then you want a better
 than normal mirror system to take advantage of the seeing. And when
 the seeing is superb? You get that maybe one or two nights in 12 or
 18 months. *Then* are you going to be satisfied with a less (or much
 less) than perfect optical system?

You also asked why we add the errors, thus giving the worst case.
 Well, how lucky are you? Can you buy the best mirror? How about all
 the others reading this? Can they buy the best mirror? No, we have
 to take the worst case. If you buy such a mirror and it turns out to
 be a little better, you're a little luckier. Lemme give you an
 example. (I may have written about this elsewhere in the MFTs or the
 RTs.)

For many years during the 1950s through the 1970s, Cave Optical
 Company ran a full page ad in _Sky & Telescope_. The telescopes
 looked like beauties. However, those of my friends and acquaintances
 who ordered a Cave mirror or telescope were uniformly displeased with
 what arrived. At first I questioned their understanding. My under-
 standing was that Tommy Cave (whom I'd met at the Astronomical League
 Convention in Madison, Wisconsin in 1954) made superb mirrors.

As it turned out, Tommy *did* make superb mirrors. It was just that
 the company didn't put those mirrors into the telescopes they were
 selling by mail. Okay, you order a Cave telescope and are dissat-
 isfied with the mirror's quality. So you take out the mirror and
 send it back to the company to be replaced with a better one. When
 that one arrives you mount it in the telescope, recollimate the
 instrument, and start observing. Boy! What lousy quality! So you
 send that mirror back for replacement with a better one. It wasn't
 until you had returned three mirrors as unacceptable that you got one
 figured by Tommy Cave himself. Nobody was dissatisfied with his
 mirrors.

Hmm. You ask about optical errors in eyepieces. The following is a
 direct quote from my, "Astronomy For The Love Of It," Appendix A:

     As with objective lenses, eyepiece lenses improperly made may
     have both chromatic aberration and spherical aberration. Any
     eyepiece you buy should be purchased with the understanding that
     it can be returned for full money back and no restocking or
     shipping or handling fees if not satisfactory. That applies to
     lots of things in life, not just eyepieces.

     The eyepiece also might have astigmatism, coma, barrel distor-
     tion, pincushion distortion, and on and on, just as camera
     lenses--which eyepieces resemble--do. The field might not be
     flat, for example.

Filters that are flat are certainly better for the column of light
 that leads from the star to your eye than a wavy filter. I know,
 Walter keeps saying that the filters and coma correction plates and
 the eyepieces themselves are so close to your eye that they distort
 the light column less. Well, if that were true--which I don't accept
 --the five meter Hale telescope on Palomar Mountain would never use
 prime focus. It would just be used with the Ross corrector, which
 widens the field. However, any astronomer knows that the sharpest
 images are at prime and the corrector's images are just a bit fuzzy.

Walter says (over and over) that I don't understand optics! Of course
 he's looking at optics from the point of view of a professional
 engineer working at _Northrop_. There he has no end of fancy
 equipment for testing. Also he has an effectively unlimited budget
 for making high quality surfaces.

 But how does that compare with the amateur telescope field? The
 aerospace industries bid and get contracts with the federal
 government. If they have cost overruns they just charge for them or
 maybe cover an overrun by charging another account that has room to
 spare. How could such charges be acceptable by a company like Meade
 or Celestron or, for that matter, Questar? One way Questar covers
 the high cost of making 1/8 wave S.A. telescopes is by charging their
 customers more per inch of aperture than a company supplying 1 or 2
 wave S.A. units. But . . . which would you rather have?

              --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist
                            All Rights Reserved
