Latest Update:  July 22, 1992

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 37

CHARLEY CHRIST asked a penetrating question in a message to me on
 Prodigy(R):  "By the way, on your telescope baffles do you use an
 infinite baffle to perceive through a black hole?"

MY RESPONSE to him:

BLACK HOLES ARE EASY TO SEE thru my telescope. Baffles aren't
 necessary on a reflector. You just have to make sure that the inside
 of your tube is painted dead black. But even that doesn't matter
 when you are observing black holes. The problem with seeing a black
 hole--whether in a telescope or one sitting in your hand--is that
 light doesn't escape from them.

HOWEVER, DUE TO THEIR INTERACTION with their surroundings, they emit
 strong X-rays and cosmic rays; therefore you must keep your eyes
 closed at the telescope to avoid eye damage. That way the black hole
 stands out from its background and is easy to perceive.

                            ɰ|
                            Ȱ|

A COUPLE OR THREE NIGHTS ago on a TV special, Willie Nelson was
 talking about his good friend Ray Charles. They both love playing
 chess. Willie said they played a game that Ray won. He said he
 wants to play Ray again--but this time with the lights on!

OVER THE BREADTH of these RTs I've commented once or twice about the
 ability of the Questar(R) 3-1/2" Maksutov telescope to outperform
 much larger commercial instruments, such as the Celestron(R) and the
 Meade(R) Schmidt-Cassegrains. I wrote about the problems of the
 Celestron and Meade instruments being inherent in the design and that
 if their lens and mirror surfaces were figured properly their
 customers couldn't afford them.

THE JUNE 1992 _Sky & Telescope_ has a Questar ad on page 602. The
 following statements are quotes from that ad:

    It is very difficult and expensive to build Schmidt Casse-
    grain optics to the same optical standards that we insist
    upon with the Maksutov. The discovery of a cost effective
    method of manufacturing Schmidts has resulted in modest
    performance from instruments that are intentional inexpen-
    sive compromises.

    The chromatic correction of the Questar Maksutov is many
    times better than the performance of the best refractive
    apochromat. It has a barrel that is a fraction of the
    length, and it is made with optical materials which are
    much more resilient to temperature changes and impact.

I'VE BEEN SAYING the same things for over twenty-five years.

I HAD A RATHER weird experience, driving home after 10 p.m. from
 Walter's house where we had backed up the BBS's hard drive onto a
 tape. Here I'm driving Chris' car and more or less listening to
 Money Radio and Gee! That voice sounds familiar! Nobody else sounds
 like my wife and here I was listening to her ask some questions of a
 talk show host about futures figured in British pounds! She had
 called in on that show two days earlier and this was a replay. She
 hadn't mentioned to me that she did that.

HOWCOME I'M GETTING all these questions about black holes by people I
 find around me? Do other people get questions about black holes . .
 . er, uh, frozen stars? (To understand that sentence you have to
 read RT19.)

DID THE EARTH MOVE or was that just the continents shifting? That's
 the title of one of my chapters in _Copulation For The Fun Of It_.
 This morning's 7.4 earthquake was the second strongest one I've
 experienced. The strongest was the one that shook us out of the
 bunks in our Land Rover camper south of Pasto, Columbia in 1971. That
 day we passed 23 landslides, caused by that quake.

THE FOLLOWING IS A message exchange from our board:
=================================================================
FROM   : BOB HOLTZMAN                           RECEIVED : YES
TO     : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      PRIVATE  : NO
SUBJECT: RT14 Message                           THREAD   : YES
FOLDER : G, "Rosenfield's Astronomy Folder"

Of course you have posed some interesting problems. An object with a
billion times the mass of Sol could be a black hole, or a very large
quasar (you didn't mention its radiation output), or simply a large
accretion of dark matter. At present, predictions of how stars end
their "lives", and what happens to them afterward is still largely
hypothetical. We still aren't sure quite how they function in terms of
their main sequence lifetime, otherwise there would be two to three
times the observed solar neutrino flux.

I suggest that it is possible that many of the noted apparent mass
anomalies may simply be burned out stars, having cooled to the point
that there is zero radiation output. Continuing that thread, it is
logical that, given the vast amount of time that it would have taken
to reach that low an energy state, many such dead stellar masses could
have accreted together forming quite massive objects, especially if
they were originally part of the same stellar cradle. Assuming the Bok
globules in the Great Nebula in Orion and with respect to their
galactic orbit, they will largely remain as a cluster throughout their
lives, and probably end their lives within that cluster, though they
would slowly gravitate together with time.

Unfortunately, I haven't seen either article to which you have
referred. But to say that the effect on a companion star is "gravita-
tionally consistent" with the effect of a black hole, is merely to say
that the effect is consistent with an object of some stellar mass that
doesn't radiate energy. Could be a burned out star that didn't nova
(for some reason that we don't yet understand), or an object that has
accreted quite a bit of dark matter (planetary accretion (but quite
large)) or even a neutron star that has stopped spinning, so that we
have not noticed its radiation pattern so that we have not noticed its
characteristic radiation pulses (or maybe it's not aligned so that we
could see them anyway).

I still get the impression that too many people are ready to jump on a
bandwagon, and interpret observations based upon what they expect to
see, rather than what is really there. Black hole theory, the infinite
compressibility of matter, is still rather shaky. While I might like
to see it confirmed, there is still no evidence to support it, and I
must remain skeptical.

Hopefully, when the supercolliders are completed, and several experi-
ments have been run and evaluated, we may have enough information on
nucleon structure to support or reject the hypothesis. Until then, I
suggest that we remain open on possible causes for gravitational
effects on stellar companions, and what appear to be extreme radiation
output patterns.

I wonder what Arp says about this. I haven't had the chance to read
the recent astro mags in months. Obviously, a leisurely trip to the
library is in order...but there is one more point. "Thirty million
light year" distance of NGC 3115...is that for real? Oh, great, you're
probably thinking, now he's attacking the Doppler shift measurements
of galactic distance. And you're right. And I'm not alone (see H.
Arp). Yes, the Doppler red shift is real...and for close objects, it
has been verified by parallax.

But for great distances, it has not yet been verified, and there may
be additional causes for an energy shift toward longer wavelengths.
One problem is the attempt to use Red shift measurements for simul-
taneously determining the distance AND radial velocity of a distant
galaxy or quasar. Some of those objects show not only extreme
distance, but superluminal velocities, according to their red shifts.

When an object shows a red shift indicating that it's traveling two,
three, five, or twenty times the speed of light, I begin to question
the validity of our standards of measurement. Either Einstein was
right, the speed of light is the universal speed limit, and something
is wrong with the redshift, or Einstein was wrong, and we'd better
come up with some new ideas!

Continuing that thread...what else could cause light to apparently
lose energy with increasing distance? Absorption and re-radiation at
lower wavelengths? Friction with an "ether"? Refraction through
massive gravitational lenses? Or if Einstein was wrong, what part(s)
of his theory need revision? Was the Lorentz-Fitzgerald contraction
in error? Is the apparent time-dilation effect of muons reaching
Earth's surface in error?

We are still in our scientific infancy. There is still much to learn.
Let's make our observations and inferences in the light of what we
know (or what we think we know), but let us also maintain a healthy
skepticism, and incorporate data from all fields of scientific
endeavor.

===============================================================
FROM   : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      RECEIVED : NO
TO     : BOB HOLTZMAN                           PRIVATE  : NO
SUBJECT: RT14 Message                           THREAD   : YES

Bob, that was an interesting message. In my chapter on Universe
creation theories I list six or seven other than the Big Bang, the
Bang Bang, and the Bang Bang Bang, which is the theory that most
cosmogonists other than H. Arp and Company accept. I got into a
discussion of that with a priest at a gem and mineral show in South
Bend, Indiana in 1987. He teaches creation theories (my kind, not the
religious kind) in a Chicago parochial high school.
  
He gets into the Kaluza-Klein theories, reversed time, the twisted and
bent space fabric, and so on. He has severe questions about the
Bang Bang Bang. He's about where I was in 1973-6, when I began to see
that the current theory--which is still with us in 1992-- doesn't
answer all mind-itching questions. I showed him the Full Contents of
my astronomy manuscript, complete with section and paragraph headings.
His comment on all that was that he'll consider using my book in his
classes.
  
About that 30 million light year distant galaxy with the possible
black hole at its center, it only can be an object with the density
and dimensions I noted before that is holding that galaxy together. If
you take away that probable black hole that particular galaxy would
dissipate.  You're saying that the object isn't a black hole, but
rather an accumulation of old stars that have faded to black dwarfs?
  
I suggest that there hasn't been enough time since that galaxy's for-
mation for that many black dwarfs to have formed. In our Milky Way
galaxy there have been searches for many years for brown dwarfs.
Current theory suggested that there should be many of them, all around
us. But we aren't finding them. Every so often there is the
announcement of a brown dwarf and then a few months later the
announcement that the first announcement was wrong.
  
Also you suggest that instead of black holes at galactic centers there
is just a massive buildup of dark bodies? C'mon, Bob. All you need
is the accumulation by crashing into one another of enough mass to
equal 3.2 solar masses and you have a body that will collapse to a
black hole. Just how many dark bodies would you need to give an
observed mass of a black hole with the mass of one billion solar
masses? (That is, the observed effect on the surrounding stars in
that galaxy.)
  
You said that, " An object with a billion times the mass of Sol could
be a black hole, or a very large quasar . . . "  A quasar? How could
a billion sun mass be a quasar? Quasars are the size of large
galaxies. Their output of energy in their central cores runs, what,
100 million times the output of our whole Milky Way.

Now how can that be a black hole? You're saying that all the energy
of a black hole is getting emitted by a black hole in the quasars?
Now if you want to toss in the concept of a *white* hole being the
engine of a quasar then we might be thinking on the same wavelengths.
(Pun not intended.)  In my theory quasars *are* white holes that
evolve first into Seyfert galaxies and then into ordinary galaxies.

Quasars are extinct. If you were to go to the location of one of the
objects we see as operating quasars and look back you'd see that you
were in an ordinary galaxy and that the Milky Way you left behind is a
quasar! Over 18 billion years there's lots of time for things to
happen.

Another subject you touched on was the apparent superluminal speeds of
objects at great distances. Those are illusions (My astronomy book
has two chapters with the word "illusion" in their titles.)  If an
object is moving away from us at .9 c and a jet is propelled away from
that object (at enough of an angle so it isn't hidden by the object
itself) at .4 c, you might say that the jet was moving at the
impossible speed of 1.25 c. However, the jet is moving at but .4 c
from the reference of its parent (future) galaxy.

You said, "One problem is the attempt to use Red shift measurements
for simultaneously determining the distance AND radial velocity of a
distant galaxy or quasar."  You suggest that those measurements don't
hold for objects so distant that we can't use parallax for determining
those distances.

But why not? For all galaxies up to the greatest distance we can
determine using parallax, the redshift of the side turning away from
us matches the blueshift of the side turning toward us and the
redshift of the object as a whole matches the distance we can
determine using parallax.

Let's consider a galaxy located twenty feet past the distance we can
measure by parallax. What happens to the redshift now? Does it turn
off and become Arpshift? No, the radial velocity of the receding
galaxy matches the receding side and the approaching side (redshifted
and blueshifted) of that galaxy. What would change its character-
istics in the distance of twenty feet (or twenty miles or twenty
million kiloparsecs or whatever)?

Bob . . . and other readers:  Note that some of the above is from my
_Astronomy For The Love Of It_.
    
     --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/
                                cosmogonist/Anti-Arpshiftologist
    >          All Rights Reserved
                   ----------------------------------------
