Latest Update:  May 16, 1991

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 6

   Back to the Allied-Chemical-Company-hates my wife story, the reason
Dow is sited in Midland, Michigan (for their worldwide chemistry
research headquarters) is that the brine wells are there. The salt
ocean that left the lime and dolostones is, to a large extent, still
there. A large part of Detroit's income over the years came from the
mining of halite, NaCl, evaporated from that ocean. By the way, [Now
you can expect a fanciful flight of prose, completely off the
subject--which, itself, is off the subject.] the corrosive atmosphere
in those deep salt mines would corrode any Detroit auto product in
less than six months.

   Thus, for many years after 1947, when they were first made, diesel
Land Rovers were taken apart on the surface and reassembled deep
underground; Land Rover bodies being an alloy of magnesium and
aluminum. Why diesel? The Detroit vehicles taken down had also been
diesels.

   My Land Rover is a diesel. The reason I ordered it that way from
the factory (for delivery to me in Brazil), was that diesel fumes are
a LOT safer than gasoline fumes. Gasoline produces CO; diesel doesn't.
When Chris and I were driving up the Andes Mountains, between
Airequipa at 7500' altitude to Puno at 12,000' altitude in Peru, our
tailpipe broke. There were no welding shops between those two cities.
Puno has been continuously occupied for 12,000 years. That was when we
were driving home from Brazil. From Puno we went north, following the
Inca trail, to Cuzco, the City of the Kings. We did that as we wanted
to visit Macchu Picchu, the "Lost City" of the Incas.

   So it would have been, get towed up the rest of the way to Puno or
get towed down the mountain . . . if we had a gas engine, as the fumes
filling the vehicle would have been poisonous. As we had the diesel,
we just opened all the windows and drove up to Puno, where the
tailpipe was welded back on. While in Airequipa, we visited the
American tracking station there. Let's see now. We have been
discussing Michigan, Brazil, Peru, and planetary zoology and geology.

   Another case for the diesel:  I have suffered the problem of a
broken fuel line twice with the Land Rover, in driving it 119,000
miles. (I was going to mention the slings and arrows of broken fuel
lines, but that metaphor's been used.)  In each case--you can't go
anywhere, you understand, as the fuel doesn't get to the INSIDE of the
motor--the cool fuel just cooled down the hot motor. You do that with
a gas vehicle and you run for your life. Diesel has a higher
combustion temperature.

   You can toss a lighted match into a can of diesel. The match goes
out. Of course, in their early genocidal experiments, the Nazis hooked
up the exhaust of a diesel truck to a sealed room full of Jews,
Catholics, disabled and otherwise handicapped Germans, foreign
nationals from countries they didn't respect, etc. Those poor folks
died, not from the nonpoisonous diesel fumes, but from oxygen
starvation.

   (I'm trying to figure how I got here in these Rambling Thoughts. If
I were writing this in WordStar (WS), I'd be able to use the Page
Preview and have up on the screen 1, 2, 8, or 30 pages so I can see
how this project was put together. But I'm using QEdit, which doesn't
have that facility.)  [Oh, I got it! I opened a WS document that I
copied from the QEdit file. (The reason to do that, instead of just
opening the QEdit file, is to not compromise the ASCII text.)  Then I
was able to run WS's spell checker and the Advanced Page Preview. I
could have opened it in WS's non document mode, but then the Advanced
Page Preview wouldn't operate.]

   I guess I was talking about Dow's brine wells. (A psych. major
might be able to do a paper on how my brain works . . . tracking
through a project like these RTs.)  Chris saved Dow that $750,000 a
year for as long as they sold that product--for all I know it might
still be in production.

   Writing this goes smoothly, unlike the multiple drafts necessary
for writing a book. When my brother Paul was opportuning me to write
science books, he commented that the most drafts he ever did of a
chapter was 23. My eyes boggled at the thought of having to do that.
Ha! I'm on my 64th draft of my chapter on the evolution of our
Universe. (It turns out I was wrong in stating I wouldn't be doing
drafts. This is at least the 15th draft of this essay.)

   I lost my camel caravan of thought. Oh, there's the reference. _Sky
& Telescope_, November 1989, page 455 has a "News Note" on the faint
blue galaxies that were so admirably portrayed on the PBS program, The
Astronomers, the series of which is ongoing at this writing.

   Hmm, faint blue galaxies in all directions at the limit of our
telescopic ability. Those 28th magnitude blue guys fit into my
cosmogony at a distance of 15 billion years. In case I did or didn't
say it before, one thing that drives me up a wall is the Lunar Rover,
which can drive me up Aristarchus any time it wants. I'm not kidding.
I want to see what turns green and brown inside that volcanic crater.

   "No, no, don't go off on tangents like that Rosenfield, or we'll
gang up on you, blasting you off the phone lines."

   Thanks, Audrey, I needed that. What drives me up the wall are the
theories--Hawking's included--that give the date of the last Bang as
10 billion years ago. (That's 10 milliard years ago, to my British
friends.)

   "Oh? You HAVE British friends, after that remark about Hawking? And
what, may I ask, is a milliard? I won't ask about that camel caravan."

   I didn't know what a milliard was, myself, h dois semanas. [That
phrase, of course, is Portuguese. That phrase means, "2 weeks ago."
There's no use in telling me to keep my Portuguese to myself; I think
in it. We ARE living in Northern Brazil, aren't we?]  My wife got sent
a pamphlet with a few pages on the craft of writing. She got it as a
courtesy of a drug company. As I grabbed it as soon as I saw it, she
doesn't get to be brainwashed by the two pages of drug information in
the center. The following Table is from that publication:

American           British and Continental        #of zeroes
                                                  following 1

million               million                       6
billion               milliard                      9
trillion              billion                      12
quadrillion           thousand billion             15
quintillion           trillion                     18
sextillion            thousand trillion            21
septillion            quadrillion                  24
octillion             thousand quadrillion         27
nonillion             quintillion                  30
decillion             thousand quintillion         33

   Economists in France, for example must pull their hair out having
to deal with Americans. How does the World Bank keep track of what
their customers are talking about?

   Hawking and colleagues say our Universe is 10 billion years old? Is
that his billion or our billion? Chris says he probably uses exponen-
tials in his manuscripts; those published in Great Britain and
elsewhere being stated in milliards and those published here in
billions. Come on, Stephen, the stars in the globular clusters range
up to ages of 18 billion years. How can the globulars be older than
our Universe?

   That argument is similar to the one that raged among cosmogonists
(I am the only cosmogonist I know of who admits to being one. The
rest, for some strange reason, call themselves, "cosmologists.") until
the 5-meter telescope on Palomar Mountain went into operation in 1952.
I studied astronomy with Professor Goran, noted above (By noted above,
that reference can be in any of these Rambling Thoughts {RT} essays.
For one thing, making references to previous individual RT essays is
risky, due to my editing the drafts. An example is the first half of
this essay, which now is in the previous RT. And, come to think of it,
all the rest of this one used to be in RT3. After I wrote that, I took
the last third of this one and moved it into RT8, and then, added the
section on the Pleiades.) in 1948-1951. As soon as I finished a class
with Goran, he had me come back the next semester and lecture to the
next class taking that subject. The Hale telescope was going,
hopefully, to get us out of the bind we were in, that our sun was
older than our Universe.

   It did that, by seeing individual giant Cepheid stars in M31, the
Great Galaxy in Andromeda. Before that date, M31 was thought to be
750,000 light years (l.y.) distant. We knew something was wrong, as
the globular clusters surrounding M31's halo were 1/9 the brightness
of the globulars surrounding our Milky Way's halo. That is, they were
that dim if M31 was close to us.

   Figuring backward from that 750,000 l.y. distance, our Universe had
to have started 1.8 billion years ago, with the Big Bang. No one could
say how that could be, considering Earth is 4.55 billion years old,
our Sun is 4.6 billion years old, our solar system is 4.61 billion
years old, and, as you'll see in another RT, the supernova that seeded
the dust and gas cloud that formed into our solar system was 6 billion
years old. [After rereading that sentence, I guess there was one
cosmogonist who grabbed the brass ring and threw out the Big Bang
theory altogether. That was Fred Hoyle, whose Steady State theory was
not compromised by those age factors.]

   So you think all those problems were solved with the 5 meter in
operation? Ha! Hee hee! In 1966 I took a science teaching course at
CMU. The 1966 text we used--as I pointed out to the professor--had 23
errors in the single chapter on astronomy. One of those was the
distance to M31 as 750,000 light years. The author of that work had
copied what the previous several editions had, making no changes.

THE PLEIADES

   I've been asked to comment on the Pleiades. The Pleiades are an
open star cluster in the constellation Taurus, the Bull. They are
located about the middle of the back of the Bull. Another open star
cluster makes up the head of the Bull. That cluster, the Hyades, has
the first magnitude star, Antares, for the eye. Note, however, that
Antares itself isn't part of the Hyades. It is closer to us, and is
moving in a different direction than the other stars of that cluster.

  "But Don, what's an open star cluster? And are there closed star
clusters?"

  There are two flavors of star clusters, Audrey, the open cluster and
the globular cluster. The open cluster, also called a galactic
cluster, is a group of stars in our Milky Way galaxy. Other galaxies,
of course, have galactic star clusters, but they are normally out of
the reach of amateurs' telescopes from the northern hemisphere. You
can probably see open clusters in the naked eye attainable Magellenic
Clouds, three irregular galaxies at southern latitudes. A given open
star cluster may have stars that aren't part of the gravitationally-
bound cluster, such as Antares, above.

   "Hold on there, Don. Don't think you can get away with a statement
like that. There are only two Magellenic Clouds, the Large and the
Small. Where did that third one come from?"

   Ah! A new territory heard from. Sorry, Jeff, there <are> three of
'em. The Small Magellenic Cloud has another component behind it and
slightly to the side--so we can see it. I know I'm trying to answer a
question about the Pleiades, but you can see in these essays I do a
lot of verving.

   Satellites of our Milky Way, the Clouds are connected to each other
by a bridge of stars and dust, and to the Milky Way by a bridge of
hydrogen gas. The Large Cloud is 169 thousand light years away and the
Small Cloud is about 200 thousand light years away. The Large and the
Small Clouds are 80 thousand light years apart.

   The Large Magellenic Cloud (LMC) has a central bar over 20 thousand
light years long and a barest suggestion of a 50 thousand light year
long arm developing in the direction away from the Milky Way.
Astronomers believe it is in the early stages of the formation of a
barred spiral galaxy. Until 1985, astronomers talked about two
Magellenic Clouds, the Large, located in the constellation Doradus and
the Small, in the constellation Tucana, which has been shown to have a
third dwarf galaxy partly behind it. The Small Magellenic Cloud is 15
thousand light years in diameter and (with the Third Cloud) has an
absolute magnitude of -17, with a total luminosity 600-million times
that of our sun. It's estimated to have perhaps a billion stars. That
Third Cloud would account for the observed, rather odd, dimensions of
the Small Cloud.

   Going back to Audrey's question about clusters, the globular star
clusters are like dwarf galaxies in themselves. In place of the few to
dozens to hundreds or thousands of stars in an open cluster, they have
an average of over 100-thousand stars each, with some clusters, such
as M15 ranging to over a million stars. The core of M15 has 7,000
stars squeezed into a volume that centered on our sun has but one
star.  Among the oldest stars known are those in the globulars; they
range up to the 18-billion year old age of our Milky Way galaxy.

   That means they must have formed first, before the other nebular
clouds in our galaxy formed into stars and solar systems. A puissant
point (I'm not sure points can be puissant, but that's what came to
mind when I was typing there.) is that most of them are made of
hydrogen and helium. There are few globular star clusters that have
any of the heavier elements in their makeup. As noted in a previous
(or future!) RT, individual stars have to be massive enough to go
supernova to seed a gassy, dusty cloud from which forms a solar system
like ours, with all the elements we find here. The stars in globular
clusters, made mostly of hydrogen and helium, aren't massive enough to
form those gigantic explosions.

   "Do all size galaxies have globulars?"

   We're not sure about that. Perhaps 200 of them orbit our Milky Way
Galaxy. More than that number shows orbiting M31 and M87.

   The Pleiades, as noted above, are an open star cluster. The stars,
often called, "The Seven Sisters," are gravitationally-bound; thus
they travel through space together. The ancients saw seven stars in
the group. How many can you see, naked eye?

   "Oh, I've seen that cluster many times in my travels, Don. I can
see the seven stars out away from the city. When I get up in the
mountains or in the desert, where the sky is crystal clear, I don't
see anymore than those seven. To what do you refer?"

   The ancients, of course, didn't have the problems of our street
lights. As long as Moon isn't interfering, most folks with clear skies
can see seven of the Pleiades. But I've seen nine of them naked eye
and one of my students saw thirteen of them. Thirteen were seen and
drawn correctly before the invention of the telescope.

   "Hold on there!"  "How can you possibly see . . . "  "We should
call you Clark Kent now, nu?"

   Good grief. You guys are really ganging up on me, aren't you.

   The stars of the Pleiades--at a distance of about 400 light years--
are spinning rapidly, doing a wild spin dance. We can see the
nebulosity around the Pleiades with amateur built telescopes as wisps
of glowing clouds. If all the roughly 100 cluster stars range--as they
do in the Pleiades--from our sun's luminosity and up, and from our
sun's temperature and up, their masses must range up to six solar
masses. Stars of that range of masses exist for 60 million years,
which therefore is the age of the cluster.

   There probably is a relationship between the mass of galactic
clusters and the mass and distance of the surrounding stars that
controls the age of the cluster until its dissolution. The oldest we
can detect are NGC 6791 in Lyra at an age of 6.3 billion years, the
cluster Melotte 66 in Puppis at 6.3 billion years, and and NGC 188 in
Cepheus at 5 billion years. Of course, those clusters can't begin to
compare with the age of the globular clusters.

           --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist
                            All Rights Reserved
